Should I Put A Mattress Topper On A New Mattress?

Should I put a mattress topper on a new mattress? — a query that often pops up when we are considering ways to enhance our sleeping experience.

Indeed, even the most inviting new mattress can be tweaked to fit our individual needs.

An interesting fact about mattress toppers is that they were originally used in luxury hotels, designed to provide an extra layer of luxury and comfort for guests.

Today, they have become a household staple, helping millions of individuals fine-tune their beds for optimal sleep.

Did you know? That a mattress topper expands the lifespan of a mattress

This article will delve into various aspects of using a mattress topper on a new mattress:

  • Unravelling the benefits of a topper on a new mattress

  • How a mattress topper can revamp the comfort of an old mattress

  • Choosing the right mattress topper for your new mattress

  • Improving breathability and airflow with a mattress topper

With insights from sleep experts, we aim to help you make an informed decision about your bed’s comfort levels.

Should You Add A Mattress Topper To A New Mattress?

The conundrum, ‘should I put a mattress topper on a new mattress?’ is rather subjective. Indeed, some may find their new mattress a perfect haven of comfort straight away, while others might grapple with its firmness level once they’ve got it home.

For more clarity, let’s dissect the potential benefits and downsides of adding a topper to your new mattress:

Benefits of Using a Mattress Topper on a New Mattress

  1. Enhanced Comfort: A mattress topper can make your new mattress feel like a boutique hotel bed — incredibly luxurious and inviting. It adds an extra layer of cosiness that could make all the difference.

  2. Extra Support: Mattress toppers can also provide additional support, a feature that proves beneficial for those experiencing back or joint discomfort. Our article on how mattress toppers can help with bad mattresses goes into this in more detail.

  3. Personalisation: A topper allows you to tweak the firmness of your new mattress without the inconvenience of a return or exchange.

  4. Protection: A topper can extend the lifespan of your mattress by mitigating direct pressure on it, which could lead to early wear and tear.

  5. Improved Breathability: Certain toppers are engineered to enhance airflow and breathability, leading to a cooler, more comfortable sleep. You can learn more about this in our blog post about mattress toppers and bed warmth.

Potential Downsides

  1. Initial Comfort: New mattresses are designed for immediate use, so a topper might seem redundant at first.

  2. Extra Cost: Quality toppers aren’t always budget-friendly. Considering you’ve already invested in a new mattress, a topper might seem like an unnecessary expenditure.

  3. Maintenance: Toppers, particularly the plush ones, may require more care and upkeep. They may also necessitate regular replacement, as discussed in this external source.

Ultimately, the choice of whether to add a topper to your new mattress hinges on personal preference and the specific needs of the sleeper. If you’re still sitting on the fence, consider exploring these alternative ways to enhance the comfort of your new mattress and exploring the purpose of a mattress topper.

Exploring The Purpose Of A Mattress Topper

First things first, what is a mattress topper used for? A mattress topper is a layer, usually about 1 to 3 inches thick, placed atop your mattress for extra comfort, support, and firmness. It offers a cost-effective method to fine-tune your bed to your personal sleep preferences.

Mattress toppers often come into play when a mattress is too firm or too soft. Their thickness and material are tailored to address specific pressure points, improve the breathability of the mattress, or enhance its overall comfort.

But even though their purpose is clear, one might wonder whether these benefits would be necessary for a brand new mattress. Well, the answer isn’t as straightforward as it might seem. Let’s delve deeper into it.

Sleep Tip: To maintain your mattress topper, check out our comprehensive guide on how to clean a mattress topper.

Making Your New Mattress More Comfortable With A Topper

If you’ve decided that a mattress topper is just the thing to bring your new mattress to the next level of comfort, then it’s time to consider how to choose the right one.

After all, not all mattress toppers are made equal, and what works for one person might not be the perfect fit for another.

 Let’s take a closer look at how to select the best topper for your needs.

A pair of hands tucking in a mattress topper

Understanding Your Needs

Before you venture into the realm of mattress toppers, it’s vital to understand what you’re looking for. The key factors to consider are:

  • Comfort and Support: Do you want your mattress to be softer, firmer, or do you simply want more support?

  • Temperature Regulation: Are you a hot sleeper looking to make your nights cooler?

  • Allergies: Do you have any allergies that certain materials might trigger?

  • Maintenance: Are you prepared for the upkeep that some toppers might require?

After understanding your needs, you’ll be better prepared to pick the perfect topper.

Choosing the Right Mattress Topper for a New Mattress

Once you’ve determined your needs, the next step is selecting the type of topper that’s best for you. The most common types are:

  • Memory foam: These toppers conform to your body shape, providing excellent pressure point relief. However, they can be warm to sleep on.

  • Latex: Latex toppers are durable, naturally hypoallergenic, and offer a good balance of comfort and support.

  • Feather: Feather toppers, also known as featherbeds, are incredibly soft and luxurious. However, they don’t offer much in the way of support.

  • Polyester Blends: These are a more affordable option. They’re hypoallergenic and easy to clean, but they may not be as comfortable or durable as other options.

Check out our in-depth guide on mattress toppers to help you make the most informed choice.

Finding the Perfect Thickness for Your Topper

Next, you’ll need to decide on the thickness of your topper. Toppers generally range from 1 to 4 inches thick. Thicker toppers provide more support and are more likely to dramatically alter the feel of your mattress. On the other hand, thinner toppers are less likely to change the firmness level of your mattress. It’s all about finding the balance that’s right for you.

Alternative Ways To Improve The Comfort Of Your New Mattress

  1. Proper Break-in Period: Allow some time for your body to adjust to the new mattress and vice versa.

  2. Right Pillow: The right pillow can make a significant difference in overall comfort and spinal alignment.

  3. Quality Bedding: Soft, breathable sheets and a plush comforter can greatly enhance your sleep experience.

Remember, whether you decide to add a mattress topper to your new mattress or not, it’s all about finding what makes your nights restful and rejuvenating. So, don’t be afraid to experiment and find the best sleep solution for you!

Can A Mattress Topper Improve The Comfort Of An Old Mattress?

You might be wondering, “If a mattress topper can help a new mattress, what about an old one?” The answer is a resounding yes! Toppers can breathe new life into an older mattress, extending its lifespan and potentially saving you from having to buy a new one. Read more about this on our detailed article here.

How Often Should I Replace A Mattress Topper?

Like most things in life, mattress toppers don’t last forever. How long a topper lasts can depend on the material and how well you take care of it. On average, you might find yourself needing to replace a mattress topper every 3 to 5 years. For more details, see this external source.

Alternative Ways To Enhance Your New Mattress

In case you decide a mattress topper is not what you’re looking for, let’s explore some alternative ways to increase the comfort and longevity of your new mattress.

Mattress Pads

Just like a mattress topper, a mattress pad is designed to sit on top of your mattress. However, pads are usually thinner and can be an excellent option for those wanting just a little bit of added softness.

They also often serve as a protective layer for the mattress, helping to prevent stains, spills, and wear. More details about mattress pads can be found on our

A hand pressing down on a mattress topper

Mattress Protectors

A mattress protector is a thin cover, somewhat like a fitted sheet, which goes over the mattress to protect it from spills, dust mites, and allergens. While it doesn’t provide extra comfort, it is an excellent tool for prolonging your mattress’s life. Read more about the importance of mattress protectors.


High-quality bedding can also make a significant difference in your sleep quality. Choosing breathable, soft sheets can enhance your comfort level. Similarly, the right pillow can ensure your neck and head are adequately supported, reducing the risk of aches and pains.

Proper Bed Frame

The right bed frame can also contribute to a comfortable sleeping environment. An adequately supportive bed frame can prevent sagging and prolong the life of your mattress. Read more on our blog.

So, while mattress toppers can provide several benefits, they aren’t the only option for making your new mattress more comfortable. Always consider your personal comfort needs and sleep habits before making a decision.

Improving Breathability And Airflow

A common problem many face with new mattresses is that they can often feel hotter than their old ones.

This is where a mattress topper can significantly help, particularly those designed to improve breathability and airflow.

A breathable mattress topper works by allowing air to circulate freely, which helps to dissipate heat and keep you cool throughout the night. Some types of toppers are particularly known for their cooling properties:

  • Latex: Latex toppers are naturally breathable and can help keep your sleeping surface cool.


  • Gel-infused memory foam: These toppers have gel beads infused into the foam, which work to dissipate heat and maintain a cooler sleeping environment.

Discover more about this topic in our article.

A hand pressing down on a mattress

Benefits Of A New Mattress Topper

Benefit Description
Improved Comfort A new mattress topper can provide extra cushioning and support, enhancing overall comfort while sleeping.
Pressure Relief The added softness of a mattress topper can help alleviate pressure points, reducing pain and discomfort.
Enhanced Durability A mattress topper acts as an additional layer, protecting the mattress from wear and tear, potentially extending its lifespan.
Temperature Regulation Some mattress toppers come with cooling properties, promoting airflow and preventing overheating during sleep.
Hypoallergenic Options Certain mattress toppers are designed to be hypoallergenic, reducing the risk of allergies and improving sleep quality for sensitive individuals.
Easy Maintenance Using a mattress topper can simplify cleaning and maintenance, as it can be easily removed, washed, and dried.


Do I really need a mattress topper for my new mattress?

While not absolutely necessary, a mattress topper can enhance the comfort of your new mattress. It offers additional support and cushioning, potentially improving your sleep quality.

Can a mattress topper help if my new mattress is too firm?

Indeed, a mattress topper can help soften a mattress that feels too firm. Opt for a thicker, plushier topper for a more significant impact on the mattress’ overall feel.

How often should I replace my mattress topper?

The lifespan of a mattress topper varies, but generally, you should consider replacing it every three to five years. The exact timeline depends on its material, usage, and care.

Are there any downsides to using a mattress topper on a new mattress?

While toppers generally enhance comfort, they might trap heat, causing sleepers to feel too warm. However, breathable and cooling toppers are available to counter this.

How do I choose the right thickness for a mattress topper?

Choosing the right thickness depends on your needs. Thicker toppers provide more cushioning and are beneficial for side sleepers, while thinner toppers offer less significant changes to the mattress’ feel.


So, should you put a mattress topper on a new mattress? Ultimately, the choice depends on your personal needs and comfort preferences. From boosting your mattress’ comfort to extending its lifespan, a topper could indeed be a beneficial addition. However, remember that not all toppers are created equal, and the key is to find one that suits your needs, in terms of its thickness, materials, and breathability.

We’ve covered quite a bit in this article, let’s do a quick recap:

  • The potential benefits of using a mattress topper on a new mattress, such as improved comfort and extended mattress lifespan.


  • The purpose of a mattress topper and its role in enhancing your sleep.


  • How a mattress topper can bring new life to an old mattress.


  • The importance of regularly replacing your mattress topper.


  • Alternative ways to make a new mattress more comfortable, like mattress pads, protectors, and choosing the right bed frame.

For more insights and expert advice, feel free to explore our other articles on similar topics:

Remember, at the end of the day, it’s all about achieving that good night’s sleep we all deserve!

– Article by Lewis Hugh

Mattress Topper - Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Dream HQ