Are Mattress Toppers Worth It?

Embarking on a quest for improved sleep often leads to one intriguing inquiry, “Are mattress toppers worth it?” This question frequently arises among potential buyers, given the sheer number of choices and polarised opinions.

But rest assured, we at Dream HQ have you covered. In this detailed review, we’ll dive deep into the world of mattress toppers, leaving no stone unturned.

Interesting fact: Did you know that a high-quality mattress topper can extend the life of your mattress by a significant margin? Fascinating, right?

Did you know? That a mattress topper expands the lifespan of a mattress

In this article, we’ll be covering:

  • Understanding what a mattress topper does
  • Unravelling the importance of a mattress topper
  • Analyzing the benefits and potential drawbacks of different types of toppers
  • Offering tips on selecting the right size and maintaining your mattress topper

Stay with us as we guide you through this intriguing aspect of sleep technology.

The Bedrock Of A Good Night's Sleep

Let’s first address what a mattress topper actually does. A mattress topper essentially is a buffer layer placed on top of your mattress.

This layer provides additional comfort and support, enhancing the firmness or softness of your mattress.

However, before diving into whether they are worth it or not, we need to answer a critical question: “Is it good to use a mattress topper?”

A mattress topper can indeed make a big difference, especially if your mattress is on the harder side, or has lost some of its comfort over the years.

With a topper, you can add some extra cushioning, making your bed more inviting and comfortable. More comfort can equate to better sleep, which is, after all, the goal.

A pair of hands putting a mattress topper over a mattress

The topper is not a one-size-fits-all solution. The type of topper that suits you depends on your sleeping patterns and preferences. For instance, side sleepers might wonder, “Is a hard mattress good for side sleepers?” or “Is foam or spring better for side sleepers?”

The answer is, it depends. The ideal topper for you could be one that moulds to your body, relieving pressure from your hips and shoulders, such as a memory foam topper.

The Flip Side of the Coin

Despite these advantages, there are instances when not to use a mattress topper. If your mattress is already overly soft, adding a topper might result in an overly plush bed that doesn’t provide the necessary support, leading to potential back pain.

Similarly, if your mattress is extremely worn out or sagging, a topper won’t be able to rectify those issues. In such a case, you might be better off investing in a new mattress. The average lifespan of a mattress in the UK can give you a good idea of when it’s time to replace your old one.

Choosing the Right Type of Mattress Topper

The type of topper you choose is contingent upon your specific needs and sleep habits.

  • Side sleepers, for instance, need to look for toppers that can alleviate pressure on their hips and shoulders. Memory foam or pocket sprung toppers are often the best choice here.

  • If you sleep predominantly on your side, the question of “What type of mattress should I get if I’m a side sleeper?” becomes particularly pertinent.

  • For hot sleepers, a topper made from breathable natural materials like cotton or bamboo can help regulate temperature and prevent overheating.

Durability And Lifespan

When exploring the value of mattress toppers, we need to consider their durability and lifespan. This naturally leads to the question, “How often should you get a mattress topper?

The answer to this is quite relative and depends on several factors such as the quality of the topper, how often it’s used, and the level of care it receives. As a general rule of thumb, a good quality mattress topper should last between 3 to 5 years.

It’s worth noting that a mattress topper is not a magic solution to extend the life of an old, sagging mattress.

However, with the right care, it can add comfort and prolong the usability of your mattress.

A hand pressing down on a mattress topper

Deciding the Importance: Mattress Vs. Topper

This brings us to an interesting debate, “Is a mattress topper more important than the mattress?” That’s like asking whether the icing is more important than the cake.

The mattress provides the core support and structure for your sleep, while the topper is there to add an extra layer of comfort and protect your mattress.

So, both components play crucial roles in delivering a good night’s sleep.

The Ideal Fit: Size Matters

Let’s get back to the question: “Is it better to have a mattress topper too big or too small?” Neither! Your mattress topper should be a perfect fit for your mattress. As the old saying goes, “Measure twice, cut once.”

When it comes to mattress toppers, the right size is not just about aesthetic; it also impacts the level of comfort and support the topper provides.

If you’re in the market for a new topper, be sure to check out our guide on
what does a mattress topper do to ensure you make an informed decision.

The Care Factor: Maintenance is Key

Just as important as the choice of topper is its maintenance. Knowing how to clean a mattress topper and how to wash a mattress topper properly can significantly extend its lifespan and maintain its comfort levels.

The topic of mattress toppers isn’t as straightforward as it seems, is it?

As you consider investing in a mattress topper, remember that every sleeper is unique, and what works for one might not work for another.

As Tom’s Guide points out, it’s a matter of personal preference and individual needs.

So, “Are mattress toppers worth it?” If you’ve made it this far, you’ll likely agree that the answer is a resounding yes, given the right circumstances.

A hand pressing down on a mattress

Adding A Layer Of Comfort

So, you’re intrigued and considering giving a mattress topper a try? Let’s delve into the world of comfort and support they offer, answering questions like “Can a mattress topper make a bed softer?” or “Can a mattress topper make your bed firmer?”

Softening Your Sleepscape

The answer to the first question is, quite simply, a resounding “Yes!” If you find your current mattress too hard or unyielding, a topper can indeed add that extra bit of plushness you’re yearning for.

Memory foam toppers are particularly well-suited to this task, contouring to your body’s shape to provide personalised support.

Reinforcing Firmness

Conversely, if your bed is overly soft, certain mattress toppers can provide additional firmness. Latex toppers, for example, are known for their durability and ability to offer firm support while still being comfortable.

To Flip, Or Not To Flip

As we dive deeper into the realm of mattress toppers, some queries might seem peculiar but are indeed quite relevant. For example, “Does a mattress topper go bumpy side up?”

You might chuckle, but the answer is not always as straightforward as you’d think! It largely depends on the specific design of the topper.

Some are meant to have the bumpy, or convoluted, side up for extra airflow and pressure relief, while others are designed to be flat side up.

Your best bet is to always check the manufacturer’s instructions to ensure you’re using your topper correctly.

Ultimately, according to an analysis by Consumer Reports, the worth of a mattress topper boils down to personal preference and individual sleep needs.

A pair of hands placing a mattress topper on top of a mattress

When A Mattress Topper Isn't Your Best Bet

While we’ve extolled the virtues of mattress toppers thus far, it’s crucial to balance the discussion with some scenarios when you might want to give them a miss. So, “When not to use a mattress topper?” Let’s explore.

A Brand-New Mattress

If you’ve just splashed out on a brand-new mattress, you might not need a topper just yet. Most new mattresses are designed with comfort and support in mind, and adding a topper might not make a significant difference.

Plus, adding a topper immediately might prevent you from accurately judging whether the new mattress is a good fit for you.

A Seriously Aged or Damaged Mattress

On the other hand, if your mattress is significantly worn out, sagging, or showing signs of damage, a topper might only be a temporary fix.

In this case, it might be more prudent to invest in a new mattress entirely. For more insights, check out our post on the
average lifespan of a mattress in the UK.

Specific Sleeping Needs

Certain sleepers might not benefit from a mattress topper. For example, side sleepers might require mattresses and toppers with specific qualities to ensure proper alignment and support.

If you’re a side sleeper, explore our resources on
is a hard mattress good for side sleepers?, is foam or spring better for side sleepers?, and should I get a firm mattress if I sleep on my side?

Softer Or Firmer: The Dilemma

Toppers can indeed transform the feel of your mattress. But, “Can a mattress topper make a bed softer?” And, “Can a mattress topper make your bed firmer?”

The answer to both questions is a resounding yes. It all boils down to the type of topper you choose.

For instance, memory foam toppers can add a plush, soft feel to your mattress, while latex or firm foam toppers can provide a firmer sleeping surface.

Interestingly, even the installation can play a role in this. For instance, “Does the mattress topper go bumpy side up?”

Most toppers are designed to be smooth on top, but egg-crate toppers, which have a bumpy surface, can offer a softer feel when installed bumpy side up.

A mattress topper on top of a mattress

Can You Sleep On Just A Mattress Topper?

“Is it OK to sleep on just a mattress topper?” This question often arises when people consider replacing their mattress or when they’re looking for a low-cost bedding solution.

It’s possible to sleep on just a mattress topper, but it’s not ideal for long-term use.

Mattress toppers lack the support that a full mattress offers, so using one alone might lead to discomfort or body aches over time.

A person putting a mattress topper over a mattress

Are Mattress Toppers More Important Than the Mattress Itself?

Some might ask, “Is the mattress topper more important than the mattress?” It’s essential to understand that the mattress and the topper are two parts of the same ecosystem, designed to complement each other.

The mattress provides the primary support, while the topper brings additional comfort and can tweak the overall feel of the bed. The magic lies in their synergy rather than in individual superiority.

How Often Should You Get a Mattress Topper?

Now onto the question, “How often should you get a mattress topper?” Just like mattresses, toppers also have a lifespan and will eventually need replacing.

However, the frequency of replacement depends on various factors like the quality of the topper, how well it’s maintained, and how much it’s used. For more information, you may want to take a look at our in-depth guide on
what does a mattress topper do.

Should You Put a Memory Foam Topper on Your Mattress?

Whether you should put a memory foam topper on your mattress depends on your personal comfort preferences. Memory foam toppers can add a plush, contouring feel to your mattress and can be particularly beneficial for side sleepers.

If you’re a side sleeper considering a memory foam topper, do explore our articles on
is memory foam OK for side sleepers? and is a pocket sprung good for side sleepers?.

Why Mattress Toppers Are Beneficial

Benefit Description
Comfort Adds an extra layer of cushioning, enhancing the comfort level of your bed.
Pain Relief Provides additional support, helping to alleviate back and joint pain by distributing weight evenly and reducing pressure points.
Extended Mattress Lifespan Serves as a protective layer, helping to extend the lifespan of your mattress by protecting it from wear and tear, as well as spills and stains.
Temperature Regulation Helps regulate temperature and keep you cool during the night, particularly those made from gel-infused memory foam or latex.
Allergy Relief Provides a barrier against allergens such as dust mites and mold, beneficial for people with allergies.


Are mattress toppers worth buying?

Absolutely. Mattress toppers can significantly enhance your comfort, provide extra support, and prolong your mattress’s life. They’re a smart investment, specifically if you’re looking to customise your bed to better fit your sleep needs.

Do mattress toppers make a significant difference?

Yes, they do. Mattress toppers can greatly improve your sleeping experience by adjusting your bed’s firmness and adding a comfort layer. Their effectiveness is largely dependent on the topper’s quality and your personal comfort preferences.

How often should I replace my mattress topper?

The need to replace a mattress topper varies based on its quality, your maintenance habits, and how you use it. Regular cleaning and care can extend a topper’s lifespan, delaying the need for replacement.

Is it better to have a mattress topper that’s too big or too small?

The size of your topper should ideally match your mattress for optimal comfort. A smaller topper may leave parts of your mattress exposed, whereas a larger one might hang awkwardly over the edges.

Should I put a memory foam topper on my mattress?

If you’re seeking a soft, body-conforming feel, a memory foam topper might be an excellent choice. They are particularly beneficial for side sleepers due to their superior pressure relief capabilities.

Final Verdict: Are Mattress Toppers Worth It?

So, we return to our central question: “Are mattress toppers worth it?” Well, the answer is not a straightforward yes or no, but rather depends on your specific situation.

Mattress toppers can indeed make a big difference, adding comfort, adjusting the firmness of your bed, and even prolonging the life of your mattress.

They can provide a cost-effective solution to enhance your sleeping experience, particularly if you’re not ready to invest in a new mattress just yet.

On the other hand, if your mattress is significantly worn out, a new topper might not do the trick. Also, a brand-new mattress might not need the addition of a topper straightaway.

And, of course, your individual sleeping preferences and needs also come into play.

To sum up, a mattress topper can be a worthwhile investment if it fits your needs and circumstances.

The key is understanding what you’re looking for in your sleeping experience and doing your research (like you’re doing right now!). You can learn more about this topic from
Tom’s Guide and Consumer Reports.

Ultimately, here at Dream HQ, our goal is to help you make informed decisions to get the sleep of your dreams.

So, if you’re still wondering about the potential benefits of mattress toppers or have any other bedding-related questions, feel free to delve deeper into our other articles.
Happy sleeping!

FAQ - Mattress Toppers

– Article by Lewis Hugh

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Dream HQ